Mentatcurated
Artificial Intelligence high · independent

Altman's open-source memo

A 2022 email surfaced from the Musk v. Altman record shows Sam Altman pitching an open-source model to OpenAI's board as a way to starve rivals of funding.

On October 1, 2022, Sam Altman emailed OpenAI's board about "open source strategy." The plan he described was to build a language model with roughly GPT-3's ability that runs on an ordinary consumer computer, and give it away for free. The reason he gave was not access or democratization. It was that releasing such a model first would "discourage others from releasing similarly-powerful models" and make it "harder for new efforts to get funded" — and that OpenAI should move before Stability AI did.

The best reason to build this and release it now is that Stability is going to do something similar. — Sam Altman, to OpenAI's board (Oct 1, 2022)

The document is dated primary evidence, pulled from the discovery record in Elon Musk's lawsuit against Altman and OpenAI. The long-running complaint that "the company called OpenAI stopped being open" is old and well-worn. What is new is the CEO, in his own words, naming a free release as an offensive move against competitors rather than a gift to the public.

The timing of its resurfacing sharpens it. The email circulated on July 20, 2026, two months after a jury dismissed Musk's claims on statute-of-limitations grounds. It has outlived the lawsuit that unearthed it, and now reads less as legal ammunition than as a plain statement of how one of the field's loudest advocates for and against openness actually weighs the choice: as a lever on rivals' balance sheets. OpenAI did eventually ship open-weight models in 2025, three years after this pitch. By then, free models had already become the standard weapon in the market it was entering.

The lenses

Novelty 3
Impact · breadth 2
Impact · depth 3
Actionable 1
Delight 2
Substance 4
Hype 2

The facts

Email dateOctober 1, 2022
SourceDiscovery record in Musk v. Altman; jury dismissed Musk's claims May 2026
The proposalFree GPT-3-class model for consumer hardware, to release before Stability AI
Open simonwillison.net →

How this connects

Tap a node to open it

How this connects