AI's right to learn, funded
A Google-commissioned economist argues that Europe's copyright exception for AI training is its single most important competitiveness lever, published just as Brussels reopens the rule that content owners want narrowed.
European copyright law already quietly lets AI companies train on almost anything they can lawfully reach. A 2019 directive permits commercial text-and-data mining of published works unless the rightsholder posts a machine-readable 'no' — an opt-out default that, in practice, made most of the open web fair game for European model-builders. On 13 July, Brian Williamson, an economist at Communications Chambers, published a paper arguing that keeping this exception intact is the most important thing the EU can do for its AI competitiveness, and that giving in to publishers and record labels who want AI training carved out would push Europe further behind the United States and China.
The input-versus-output line he is selling to regulators is the same line his funder is about to defend in court.
The timing is the point. The European Commission is required to reopen these rules this year, and rightsholders are lobbying to tighten them; a March 2026 European Parliament resolution already signalled the current framework may be too permissive. Williamson's paper is a shot fired into that review. It is also Google-commissioned, which the newsletter that surfaced it flagged plainly, and it is not neutral analysis but one funded voice in a crowded fight where a competing study values what is at stake for the EU at hundreds of billions of euros a year.
What makes it worth reading past the funding label is a structural irony. Williamson's line is that AI training on inputs should be freely allowed and copyright enforced only on what the model outputs. That exact question is now in front of the EU's top court in its first generative-AI copyright case, brought by a Hungarian publisher whose articles Google's chatbot summarised. The defendant is Google. The argument its funded economist is making to the Commission is the argument its lawyers are about to test before the judges.
The lenses
The facts
How this connects
Tap a node to open it