Stop building it
The Verge's Nilay Patel argues the AR glasses everyone is racing to ship can't be built without an always-recording camera streaming to the cloud. The privacy invasion isn't a bug to patch. It's the product.
The usual smart-glasses argument is about safeguards: add a brighter recording light, a clearer beep, better consent norms. On a recent Vergecast, Nilay Patel reframed it as a question about the hardware itself. To build the consumer AR glasses the whole industry thinks is the next platform, he says, you have to sit an always-on camera next to someone's eyes and ship the video off to the cloud, because nothing small enough to live in a glasses stem can make sense of a continuous video feed on a wearable power budget. The alternative is a Vision-Pro-sized headset with an external battery. Those, he says, are the current choices. And if the only way to make the product is to record everyone around you, the honest conclusion might be that we shouldn't make it.
The trade-offs required to make this product are so high at a societal level that we should stop it. — Nilay Patel
Patel's version of the constraint is sharper than the evidence strictly allows. On-device chips keep getting better, and 'no processor could ever do this locally' is rhetoric more than physics. But the always-on-and-off-to-the-cloud pattern he's describing has a shipping instantiation the same week he said it. Meta has been testing 'super sensing' prototype glasses that record audio continuously and snap a photo every few seconds, then upload the extracted metadata to Meta's servers so an AI can answer questions about the wearer's day. The raw footage reportedly isn't even kept for the wearer; the point is the query, not the recording.
The tell is the little light. Meta has spent years pointing to the LED that flicks on when its glasses record as proof they aren't covert surveillance, and this same week pushed a software update that disables the camera if you cover it. Yet executives reportedly don't want that light on when super-sensing mode runs, because always-on recording with a blinking indicator is a hard sell. So the one visible cue a bystander gets is set to disappear at exactly the moment recording becomes constant. Patel's abstract worry is that this product class asks you to invade the privacy of everyone in the room, most of whom never agreed to anything. It turns out to describe a device in the lab, not a hypothetical.
The lenses
The facts
Concepts
How this connects
Tap a node to open it